This recipe is Copyright of ChefDeHome.com

One of family-favorite recipe from my kitchen to yours!

Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker

How about coming home from work, and a restaurant quality Indian Butter Chicken dinner is waiting for you?! Sounds tempting? Isn't it?  This is the charm of slow cooker, my friends. Today, I'm giving you one more reason to dust-off your slow cooker, for this easy Indian homemade Butter Chicken dinner!!

Ready to ditch the delivery?! :-)

If you like Indian Food, this Slow Cooked Butter Chicken will be your new family favorite! I promise!

Just like you, I also get so busy or lazy some days that it just not feel like to stand in kitchen.  Specially these days, when Sun is shining so bright and my apartment kitchen is often 100+ degrees due to sun-facing from 2 directions. Since it is still little pleasant during early morning hours.... I love finishing the dinner prep in morning and then just enter kitchen for sometime in evening.... and dinner is ready! To fit my life-style, I have adapted many of Indian Curries or our other chicken dinner favorites,  to cook in slow cooker.

Slow Cooker gives me option to serve my family homemade dinner... no matter how day goes! and that's one of the BEST thing in my book.

Indian Butter Chicken Curry in Slow Cooker for easy Indian Dinner | chefdehome.com

All effort needed to make this Butter Chicken is in blending the marinade and sauteing some onions in butter! Obviously! You can't have authentic Butter Chicken without butter. Right? However, butter chicken is not about butter and butter only... In-fact, it does not need a LOT of butter, at all! 

I'm an instant cook and often, especially with curries, it all depends on available protein and mood! :) It all starts with phrase "Let's eat Butter Chicken Today!" Hence, no time to marinate chicken... So, I skip long marination. Just mixing marinate in chicken and then leaving on kitchen counter, while I slice onion, and saute. At the max, make breakfast tea for Vishal..... about 15-20 minutes and then I add chicken to the pan. And frankly, those 2-3 minutes in pan with butter, garam masala, and onions brings out lot of flavor. Plus slow cooking does the rest job for me. For the record, I never have missed long-marination in flavor.

Restaurant Style Butter Chicken served with Basmati Rice for Easy Indian Dinner | chefdehome.com

Butter Chicken as name suggests, is Indian chicken main course, cooked in butter and Indian spices.... because butter and spices make everything taste better! :) These two key components are must to make a delicious Butter Chicken. However,  you don't need a stick of butter to make butter chicken flavorful. Butter does add distinct flavor, but there are also other ingredients that make Butter Chicken so flavorful.

Garam Masala is one main STAR spice (spice blend) used in classic Butter Chicken. This only spice is king of Indian Spices and adds ton of flavor! Just like Italian Herb De Provence or Chinese Five Spice, Indian Garam Masala is blend of potent Indian spices that alone can make or break a dish! 

So, to get restaurant style flavor in Butter Chicken, you have to add one main Indian spice - Garam Masala, to it! 

Few other ingredients that give Butter Chicken, a lush and creamy, restaurant like texture are tomatoes, almonds, yogurt, and finishing touch of little heavy cream. A very complex tasting dish sums up in these simple ingredients..... Each of these equally contribute to that addictive "restaurant-style" creamy and fragrant chicken.

TIP: I avoid using a lot of butter... However, just before serving, you can add a teaspoon of salted butter in hot bowl of Butter Chicken, for that extra punch of flavor.... exactly like it is served in restaurants. :)

Creamy and Rich Indian Butter Chicken | chefdehome.com

This butter chicken recipe is very simple.  Also, I have kept method of preparation very simple and standard. You can say, this recipe has evolved over-time from my earlier Butter Chicken recipe. From standard I mean, using this recipe, now you can make butter chicken, at home, with any cooking method of your choice. 

1. Slow Cooker  - Follow the recipe instructions as-is below.
2. Oven - Follow up-to step 4. Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. After step 4, transfer the chicken to an oven-prove dish, cover with aluminium foil or a heat-safe lid, cook in oven for 25 minutes, then uncover lid and cook for 10 minutes. 
3. Stove Top: Follow up-to step 4 using a deep heavy bottom pan (like a dutch oven) instead of a saute pan. Then add 1/4 cup water, cover and cook covered on medium-low heat for 20-25 minutes or until chicken is fully cooked.

You know, after looking at so tempting pictures, I'm drooling and famished too! Time to grab some lunch! You all have a great day! - Savita

Slow Cooker Restaurant Style Butter Chicken for an Easy Homemade Indian Chicken Dinner | chefdehome.com

Homemade Naan or Rice are quintessential side for Indian Butter Chicken Dinner!!! Here as few recipes for you:

Craving for more? Sign up for the Chef De Home Newsletter for a plateful of contents delivered to your inbox! And connect with me on Facebook, Google, Twitter and Pinterest for all of the latest updates.

Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker

Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker
Total Time Prep Time Cook Time Difficulty Easy Yields 4 Servings Serves 4 Notes Needs 1 hr 25 minutes on high Or 3 hours on slow.
Smart Swap Add sauted bell pepper into chicken before serving, to make portion more substantial.

Ingredients

    Butter Chicken Marinade
  • 1/3 Cup Yogurt  (non-fat greek yogurt, 4-5 heaping tablespoons)
  • 1/4 Cup Almonds  (silvered, or blanched and peeled whole almonds)
  • 2 Tomatoes  (use 1 cup canned crushed tomatoes or 2 grated ripe red roma tomato)
  • 1.5 tbsp Tomato Paste  
  • 1.5 tsp Garam Masala  
  • 1 tsp Chili Powder  (indian deggi chili powder, or hot paprika, or 1/2 tsp cayenne (add more if like spicy))
  • 1 tsp Cumin Powder  (dry roasted cumin seeds, ground)
  • 2" Ginger  (fresh ginger root)
  • 3 Garlic  (cloves, peeled)
  • 1/2 tsp Salt  (adjust per taste)
  • Butter Chicken
  • 1.5 lbs Chicken  (boneless chicken thigh, cut into 2-3 inch cubes)
  • 2-3 tbsp Cilantro  (coriander leaves, chopped, for garnish)
  • 1 tbsp Honey  (adjust per taste)
  • 2-4 tbsp Heavy Cream  (adjust per taste, I add upto 1/3 cup based on tartness of tomatoes)
  • 3 tbsp Unsalted Butter  
  • 1/2 Cup Red Onion  (medium onion, sliced to thin half-moon slices)

Directions

Hide Step Photos
  • Step for Recipe - Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker
    1. Marinade: In a food processor jar, add all the chicken marinade ingredients, leaving 1/2 tsp of garam masala and all of yogurt, then process to make a fine puree. (if mixture is hard to blend, add 1 tbsp water)
    Step for Recipe - Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker
    2. Transfer marinade to a wide bowl, and mix in yogurt. Then add cubed chicken meat and coat into the marinade. Set aside for 15-20 minutes
    Additional Notes
    If cooking in slow cooker, just leave aside for 15-20 minutes. If cooking in oven, it is best to marinade for 1 hour, overnight is even better.
  • Step for Recipe - Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker
    3. Infuse Flavors: In meantime, heat 2 tbsp butter in a wide pan. Saute onion in butter on medium heat until soft and fragrant (2-3 minutes). Now, add remaining 1/2 tsp garam masala and continue saute for 1 more minute.
    Step for Recipe - Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker
    4. Transfer the marinated chicken with all marinade and remaining 1 tbsp butter and honey into the saute pan. Cook chicken in pan for 5 minutes on medium-high heat or until curry looks darker color.
    Additional Notes
    This step is very important. It cooks off raw texture of tomatoes, and reduce watery-ness of yogurt. This step also awakens the butter and spice flavor.
  • Step for Recipe - Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker
    5. Slow Cooker: Transfer everything in slow cooker with 1/4 cup water (or chicken stock for more flavor). Cook on high for 1.25 hours Or on slow for 3-4 hours.
    Additional Notes
    Cooking time varies based on size of chicken pieces. I cut it into 2-3 inch cubes which generally takes 3-4 hours on slow. If cutting big pieces, always make sure chicken is well cooked, before serving.
    Step for Recipe - Restaurant Style Butter Chicken in Slow Cooker
    6. Before serving, after the cooker timer is up, add heavy cream and mix well. Taste and adjust salt. Leave on warm until ready to serve.
    Additional Notes
    Please note, cream makes butter chicken creamier. Butter chicken may look little not creamy when just finished cooking. Finishing with cream will get that restaurant quality creaminess.
Savita's Notes:

Don't have Slow Cooker? You can also cook Butter Chicken in oven. Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. After step 4 above, transfer the chicken to an oven-prove dish, cover with aluminium foil or a heat-safe lid, cook in oven for 25 minutes, then uncover lid and cook for 10 minutes.

Cooking time varies based on size of chicken pieces and also on marination time. Remember, small chicken pieces and long marinated chicken will cook way faster.

Imp If you can't find ripe red tomatoes, please use canned. Pale and dull tomatoes will make sauce watery and also dull the taste as well.

Low Carb Pairings:
Pear and Asparagus Salad
Tandoori Chicken Salad with Mango Dressing (skip chicken)
Roasted Veggies Salad with Coconut Curry Dressing

© Chef De Home. All contents and images are copyright protected. Please do not use content/images without prior permission. If you want to use recipe instructions, re-write the recipe in your own words, and link back to this post with credit to ChefDeHome for the Recipe Origin.

Comment

Please enter your comments/suggestions below.
Required fields are marked - *.
Rate this recipe:
Send me future posts.
ChefDeHome Comment Avatar

83 comment(s)

  1. Hello,thanx for the recipe ,the taste was great,but the color turned to dark yellow mustard color,I maybe because I added 3/4 tsp of turmeric powder ?

    Hello Ibrahim, I'm certain its turmeric. This recipe does not need/call for Turmeric Powder. The color of curry comes from chili powder and tomato. I'm not sure why you chose to add turmeric?
  2. Thanks for your response. The floating pop up is the following ribbon: 1. Family Dinner Recioes 2. Easy chicken recipes 3. Chipotle Mexican grill I'm on an iPad

    I see what you talking about. I'll contact that Ad agency to get it down asap. Thank you so much, John.
  3. Please get rid of the floating pop up. It is annoying.

    Hi John, our regrets for the inconvenience. We will try to find out what is causing floating popup. Did it block your view? Were you using mobile or desktop? Thanks for providing feedback.
  4. I am trying this recipe soon, but since my family is in a low carb diet most will have salad as a side instead of nan or rice. Which salad would be perfect for this? I would love to try one from your recipes.

    Hi Dianka, there are 100+ salads on blog and you had me thinking which one should I recommend to you. I have updated three, almost no-carb salads, in Recipe Notes which will go great on side of Butter Chicken. If your family likes quinoa or chickpeas in salads, there are plenty of options to explore. Check out the "Salads" section from Recipe Menu. I hope your family enjoy Butter Chicken. Happy Cooking!
  5. I have followed your recipe but mine gasnt turned out the typical colour of butter chicken. It brown rather than the orange colour. Why would this be?

    Hi Kara, the orange color of butter chicken comes from red tomatoes and white cream. There is nothing in this recipe which yields brown color. Only think I can guess is: cooking red onion too long which becomes caramelized brown, or slow cooker temperature too high which burnt the sauce? I hope it gives you some idea. -Savita
  6. Hi Savita, I've made this for to have it later. Will it freeze ok? And if I do, do I add the cream before it goes in the freezer or after defrosting it. Thank you

    Hi Graham, it should freeze okay. You can freeze it with cream too. I would prefer to add it fresh after reheating. That way I can fix the consistency better. I hope it helps.
  7. Instead of almonds, would it be possible to use almond flour? If so, what amount would you recommend?

    Hi Judy, I have never used almond flour for this recipe. So, I'm not sure how it will hold-up with the slow cooking. Almonds are used in recipe for some nutty texture. I can imagine using almond butter or cashew butter but almond flour.
  8. Hi Savita, Thanks for sharing this recipe. Your website is truly a miracle for foodlovers; tasty recipes and very quick and easy. I tried the butter chicken last week and it really was amazing, until I overcooked it a bit (5hrs instead of 304 in a V large slow cooker) - it went a bit dark round the edges but still tasted great. I'm a big fan and I'm sharing with friends and family. Thanks again for sharing- I love your work!
  9. This recipe is so amazing! I didn't have honey so used pure Hawaiian vanilla extract. Was nervous but it turned out great with such a complexity of flavour. Best thing I have ever made!!

    Sarah, I'm so glad you enjoyed this butter chicken recipe! Honestly, I never used vanilla with Indian flavors and now I want to try this Hawaiian version for sure! :) Happy to hear you liked the flavors. Cheers! ~Savita
  10. Do you have any suggestions for substitutions to make this nut free? My family can only eat peanuts, not other nuts.

    Hi Heidi, I always use almonds or cashews for this recipe. However, you can use seasme seed paste, or melon/pepita seeds (without skin) instead too. Also, if you can't use any of these, skip nuts an add more heavy cream when chicken is cooked. I hope it helps. (peanut butter will leave a peanutty taste in curry, if that's okay with you then peanuts can be used as well.)
  11. Great recipe. I've decided to try and make as many of the recipes on your website as possible, starting from today with the butter chicken, garlic naan, and basmati jeer rice. :) What cup measurements do you use? The American cup? (eg. 1 cup = 240mL, 1tsp = 5ml, etc.)? Cheers

    Hi Ashleigh, thanks for sweet words. I'm so glad you planning to try recipes. I must say, you starting with pretty good menu. I hope you enjoy. Also, yes, all measurements are American Cup. Please free to ask any question you have while cooking. Mark your question with ASAP if you need me to respond ASAP :) Happy Cooking! Cheers!
  12. This may be a long shot but is there any way of making this using a pressure cooker?

    Hi Natasha, amazingly this recipe works good for slow cooker as well as plain old heavy bottom pan. For pressure cooker, after 4th step add to pressure cooker pot with 1/4 cup more water. Cook for 10 minutes or until chicken is tender. I would add more cream after done and also adjust seasonings to taste. I hope it helps.
  13. Simple and tasty. It looked like the photo but I did add a little more water than the recipe called for. I cooked it in the slow cooker on high for two hours and kept it on warm another two hours before serving.

    Karla, thanks so much for feedback. I'm glad you like butter chicken. Water requirement for this recipe has amazed me. A few before you found sauce runny... where it always comes out perfect for me the way it is. I think, it has to do with kind of yogurt used. Which yogurt did you use? Greek thick or plain?
  14. Hi! If I wanted to add potatoe - when would be the best time to add it in?

    Hi Payal, I would add potatoes with the chicken in slow cooker. cutting it in big pieces (2 inch) will be better since very small size will disappear in gravy. I hope it helps.
  15. Do I need to peel the ginger before I put it in the food processor?

    yes, please peel the ginger before adding to food processor.
  16. I've tried, I think, more than 3 recipes to make butter chicken in slow cooker and this, by far, turned out most delicious! Can't wait to try more of your recipes. thanks and keep posts coming! :D

    Hi Joe, I'm glad you enjoyed this recipe. Thanks for taking time to write feedback.
  17. That recipe sounds great! I just bought a slow cooker and want to try it. For which size of slow cooker is the recipe ? I have a 6,5 liter slow cooker.

    Hi Sarah, I used 3.5 quarts cooker for this recipe. I often even cook butter chicken in 2 quarts cooker. I hope it helps. Let me know if you have any more questions.
  18. pinned for later - must try

    thanks for pin, my friend! I hope you get chance to try it soon.
  19. Load More Comments